| 2012 - Hammers Nick Sanchez Rashiyd Shabazz Darrel Oneill Shane Boone Joe Deluca Ahmed Allen Akeem Gooding Mike Hernandez Craig Kelly Jelani Winfield Rob Luizzi |
| 2011 - Butchers Tommy Kieblesz Chris Kieblesz Jim Lynch Claude Sharpe Mike Sacamanca |
| 2010 - Hammers Nick Sanchez Joe Deluca Jelani Winfield Derek Phelps Mike Hernandez Ahmed Allen Jaime Sanchez Menelick Eaddy Craig Keelty Rob Luizzi |
| 2009 - Hammers Nick Sanchez Allen Watson Joe Deluca Jelani Winfield Karl Young Craig Keelty Menelick Eaddy Rob Luizzi |
| 2008 - JP's Danny Reyes John Phelan John Cesario Bradley Washington Bryant Appollon Jarmaine Grant |
| 2007 - JP's John Phelan John Cesario Jarmaine Grant Danny Reyes Ira Miller |
| 2006 - JP's Danny Reyes John Phelan Chris Guadalupe Shane McKeon Jermane Grant |
| 2005 - Butchers Kevin Baumgardner Mike Englert Jimmy Lynch Tommy Kieblesz Chris Kieblesz |
| 2004 - Butchers Kevin Baumgardner Mike Englert Jimmy Lynch Tom Fox John Munari Tommy Kieblesz Nick Mc Keon |
| 2003 - Butchers Kevin Baumgardner Mike Englert Jimmy Lynch Tom Fox John Munari Tommy Kieblesz Nick Mc Keon |
| 2002 - Tar Heels John Rafferty Chris Kraft Michael Herring |
| 2001 - Rookies Joe Allen Bingo Braxton Duke Braxton Kunka Braxton Billy Gallager Pete Gordon Tom Gordon Al Pyne Jim Van Winkle |
| 2000 - Tar Heels John Rafferty Andrew Sikiric Steven Sikiric Timmy Banoff Chris Kraft |
| 1999 - Tar Heels John Rafferty Matthew Polarolo Andrew Sikiric Steven Sikiric Timmy Banoff |
| 1998 - Black Kurt Wesch Tom McManus Dan Cavallo Tom Rizzi Joe Diaz Mike Killcommons |
| 1997 - Hammer Rob Luizzi John Wall John Monari Chris Kraft Kurt Stork |
| 1996 - Tar Heels John Rafferty Chris Kraft Andrew Sikiric Matthew Polarolo Timmy Banoff |
| 1995 - Tar Heels John Rafferty Chris Kraft Andrew Sikiric Matthew Polarolo |
| 1994 - Hammers Kevin Baumgardner Tommy Kieblesz Chris Kieblesz John Munari John Wall Joe Rumenick Brett Malverty Vito Razza Bob Luizzi |
| 1993 - Black Tom McManus Kurt Wesch Charles Guardino Mike Killcommons Tom Rizzi John Kearns Paul Rogers |
| 1992 - Black Charlie Guardino Mike Killcommons Rich Scott Tom McManus Tom Rizzi Kurt Wecsh |
| 1991 - Bullets Chris Brandl Bill Coultaus Anthony Fellin Dennis Gregory Tom McCahill Keith Perry |
| 1990 - Cats John Urbielewicz Ted Jankowski Wally Czochanski Wally Kirejczyk Mike Szymanski Fred Suzel |
| 1989 - Butchers Kevin Baumgardner Tom Baumgardner Nick Falatico Mike Falatico Tom Fox John Minski |