• 2024- Help Wanted (defeated O'Neill's)
• 2023- Help Wanted (defeated O'Neill's)
• 2022- Foul Poles (defeated Thunder)
• 2021- Thunder (defeated Foul Poles)
• 2020- No Season (Covid-19)
• 2019- Help Wanted (defeated Foul Poles)
• 2018- Thunder (defeated Foul Poles)
• 2017- Foul Poles (defeated Thunder)
• 2016- Foul Poles (defeated Vipers)
• 2015- Thunder/O'Neill's (co-Champions)
• 2014- Thunder (defeated Vipers)
• 2013- Thunder (defeated Bridie's)
• 2012- Thunder (defeated Bridie's)
• 2011- Ridgewood Moose Lodge 1642 (defeated Butchers)
• 2010- Thunder (defeated Ridgewood Moose Lodge 1642)
• 2009- Key Food - Glenn's Team (defeated Thunder)
• 2008- Thunder (defeated Tony & Frankie's Fast Food - Glenn's Team)
• 2007- Foul Poles - Glenn's Team (defeated Phoenix)
• 2006- Thunder (defeated Cyclones-Maspeth Federal)
• 2005- Thunder (defeated Blaze)
• 2004- O'Neill's (defeated C.J.'s)
• 2003- Blaze (defeated Thunder)
• 2002- Thunder (defeated Blaze)
• 2001- Thunder vs Lost Time (no champion due to 9/11)
• 2000- Thunder (defeated Blaze)
• 1999- Thunder (defeated Seals)
• 1998- Thunder (defeated Blaze)
• 1997- UNM (defeated Blaze)
• 1996- UNM (defeated Storm)
• 1995- Thunder (defeated UNM)
• 1994- UNM (defeated Thunder)
• 1993-
• 1992- Foul Poles (defeated UNM)
• 1991-
• 1990-
• 1989-
• 1988-
• 1987-
• 1986-
• 1985-
• 1984-
• 1983-
• 1982-
• 1981-
• 1980-
• 1979-
• 1978-
• 1977-
• 1976-
• 1975-